How to Choose the Right Compost Bin for Your Garden

Choosing the right compost bin for your garden depends on your needs, available space, and budget. Consider the size, material, aeration, insulation, and maintenance requirements before making a decision. A compost bin can benefit your garden and the environment by reducing waste and providing natural nutrients for plants.

Types of compost bins

Composting at home is a great way to reduce waste and make use of kitchen scraps and yard trimmings. However, choosing the right compost bin can be overwhelming, as there are many different styles available. To help you choose the best option for your needs, we’ve outlined some of the most common types of compost bins.

Stationary bins

Stationary bins are the simplest type of compost bin and are often made from plastic or wood. These bins consist of a container with an open bottom, which allows worms and other beneficial microorganisms to enter from the soil. Stationary bins require little maintenance beyond regular turning or layering of materials and may take anywhere from six months to a year to produce usable compost.

  • Typically made from plastic or wood.
  • Simplest design.
  • Require little maintenance.
  • Might take up to a year to produce compost.

Tumbler bins

Tumbler bins are designed to make turning easier by providing an enclosed container that can be rotated to mix the contents inside easily. These types of composters come in single batch and multiple batch varieties.

Single batch tumblers

Single-batch tumblers have only one chamber, meaning that all materials must be added at once, and once full, left to decompose until ready for use. These types of tumbling composter typically work faster than stationary designs since they require less manual labor for mixing.

Some models even offer features like ventilation systems or double-wall construction that insulates the contents better.

  • Easier mixing
  • Faster than stationary designs
  • One chamber
  • Limited capacity
  • Models may have additional features such as ventilation systems
Multiple batch tumblers

Multi-batch tumblers have two-sided chambers, allowing you to add fresh material while allowing existing matter time on its own side. As this design makes it easy to separate fresh material from mature content.

These devices are similar in design to the single batch model, but feature two or more chambers connected by a central axis. This model avoids the problem of waiting for one batch to finish decomposing before adding fresh material as there are multiple compartments.

  • Can separate fresh materials from mature ones.
  • Ideal for larger quantities.

Worm composting bins

Worm composting is an efficient way to reduce household waste and produce nutrient-dense compost for plants. These small scale bins utilize worms to break down organic matter, and they come in several styles.

The most popular type is the worm bin, which can be made from plastic tote boxes or wooden boxes. Inside these containers, worms consume kitchen scraps and other organic material and transform into high-quality worm castings.

  • Efficient
  • Utilize worms
  • Can be relatively cheaply made with a variety of materials such as plastic tote boxes or wooden boxes

With any type of compost bin design you choose you may customize it further:Adding add-ons like spigots on the bottom allow you to collect valuable “compost tea,” liquid fertilizer that can be used directly on garden plants, dilute it with water and start a hydroponic operation.

Composting at home is both eco-friendly and sustainable. Knowing what kind of composter you’d like would make your garden flourish while reducing food scraps’ negative environmental impact.

What is Compost?

Compost is a mixture of decayed organic matter, such as leaves and food scraps, that is used to improve soil quality and provide nutrients for plants. [Wikipedia]

Understanding materials for composting

Composting is the natural process of recycling organic matter into nutrient-rich soil. A good compost pile requires a mixture of “green” and “brown” materials. Green matter, which is high in nitrogen, adds moisture to the pile and provides the necessary nutrients for rapid decomposition. Brown matter, also known as carbon-rich, provides structure and allows air to circulate inside the pile.


Green materials are usually fresh, moist items that decompose quickly. They are often used as activators since they contain more essential nutrients that can fuel the microbes needed for a successful composting process.

Grass clippings

Grass clippings make an excellent source of green material for your compost bin. They provide nitrogen, which is essential for healthy plant growth while helping to keep the pile moist enough to support microorganisms.

To get the most out of grass clipping added to your compost bin or pile

  • Avoid adding lawn clippings treated with herbicides or pesticides.
  • Always mix your green stuff with browns like shredded paper to ensure adequate aeration.
  • Use them in moderation since they tend to break down rapidly and can form a slimy layer if overused.
Fruit and vegetable scraps

Fruit and vegetable scraps are essential components when it comes to making rich manure from your backyard garden waste. They not only add vitamins but also provide acidity crucially needed by certain types of beneficial bacteria!

When using fruit and vegetable scraps:

  • Always cut them into smaller pieces so that they break down faster in your bin or pile.
  • Remember not to include fats or oils because these will attract pests like rats.
  • Try tossing them underneath another layer before covering everything up with some soil.
Coffee grounds

Coffee grounds are excellent additions in small amounts since they neutralize odors in all homemade fertilizer formulae!

They contain a considerable amount of caffeine as well as acids that boost the activity of crucial bacteria.

Here’s how you can use coffee grounds in your compost bin:

  • Make sure the wet ones are mixed well with brown components like dry leaves, paper, and twigs to prevent them from sticking together.
  • Avoid pouring too many coffee grounds into the compost pile since they can make it acidic.


Brown materials make up most of our gardens’ waste as they include dead plant matter and wood or bark chips. They provide aeration so that beneficial microorganisms can flourish in your compost pile.

Dry leaves

Fallen leaves in autumn are brown in color, offering a readily available source of browns for any DIY gardeners out there!

When using dry leaves:

  • Shred them into smaller pieces so they break down more quickly.
  • Always add water to keep the pile moist.

Sawdust is another carbon-heavy component which makes an excellent choice to mix with your greens!

Bear in mind when using sawdust:

  • It acts as an absorbent material and should never be used alone since it doesn’t break down quite quickly.
  • Mix sawdust sparingly with green matter as too much will slow down the decomposition process.
Shredded paper

Shredded papers from mailboxes together with cardboard waste offer an easy solution if one is looking for new organic materials for backyard gardening! They create air pockets within the pile, thus promoting airflow between layers.

In addition to that:

  • Mix wet shredded papers thoroughly with other dry browns to ensure proper decomposition inside your bin or pile.

Knowing what type of materials suitable for composting significantly influence how to choose a compost bin that meets all requirements needed for successful gardening activities. With proper care and maintenance, your backyard garden waste should produce nutrient-rich soil rich enough to support healthy plants!

Size considerations for compost bins

Composting is a great way to reduce waste while creating nutrient-rich soil for your garden. A key aspect of successful composting is choosing the right compost bin size to fit your needs. The right size depends on several factors such as the amount of waste you generate, the size of your garden, and how much time you want to spend maintaining the compost.

Small compost bins

Small compost bins are ideal for homeowners who generate minimal amounts of kitchen and yard waste or have limited outdoor space. These containers generally have a capacity between 1-20 gallons and are perfect for apartment balconies or small patios. In general, small-sized bins come in the following options:

  • Countertop Compost Bins – For those who live in apartments or condos where outdoor space is not ample, countertop compost bins work best as they can handle organic food and paper waste.
  • Tumbler Compost Bins – They are adaptable to smaller spaces than traditional backyard models, because they can rest up against a wall without hindering access from any particular side.

While small-sized containers may be convenient in terms of storage space, they may not always be suitable if you produce higher amounts of green waste.

Medium compost bins

Medium-sized ones typically range from 30-80 gallons making them an optimal choice for people with moderate lawns or gardens that may produce fall leaves, grass clippings, fruit scraps etc., generating more organic matter than what can be easily managed by a small container.Some examples:

  • Wooden Slatted Compost Bin – This type permit air circulation like tumbler-style models with slower heat buildup that enables homemade soil creation over many months but makes it possible to collect materials throughout this period.
  • Enclosed Bin with Welded Wire Mesh Sides – They only require basic assembly and provide cheapness when needed since these often could be fashioned out of materials either on-hand or from a hardware store.

Medium-sized bins are designed to be manageable in size and do not occupy much room in most outdoor settings, but may require more effort for moisture control, regulate the correct amount of gas lighting, turn contents weekly, pest deterrence and weed growth prevention.

Large compost bins

Large-scale home gardens that yield high volumes of organic matter will benefit from giant containers with an ability of 100 gallons or more.Examples:

  • Stationary Composter – It is a large wooden box situated in one spot that has compartments and anti-locking mechanisms to keep wildlife away and acts as add-ons beside bin walls particularly efficient to prevent soil expansion during wet seasons.
  • Cover Lid Composting Insert – Popular choice because it is uncomplicated when needing extra space quickly can include a lifted interior tray that assists aerate garden waste beginning inside the bottom section finished compost is ready out once full let’s users build layers quicker than typical open-walled models.

Large compost bins give users greater flexibility by allowing more variety in their waste material collection. They could accommodate heavier items like branches, shrubs as well as grass cuttings which smaller composters wouldn’t handle efficiently without clogging the airflow through the pile. It has multi-chamber facilities where different levels may house divergent stages of bio-degrading elements useful for faster decomposition timescale enabling larger sections readily available for use come harvest time.

Comparing costs of different compost bins

When considering buying a compost bin, it is important to know how much you are willing to spend, and what type of bin will fit within your budget. Fortunately, there are many types of compost bins available at different price points. Here we will compare the costs of three different types: stationary bins, tumblers and worm composting bins.

Stationary bins

Stationary bins tend to be the least expensive option for home gardeners who want to start composting. They can cost as little as $50 but can go up to $200 depending on the size and material. Some models even come with aeration tubes or ventilation panels that help maintain airflow in the pile.


  • Inexpensive
  • Good option for those new to composting
  • Durable and long-lasting if made from high-quality materials such as cedar wood or recycled plastic
  • You can build your own using recycled materials like pallets or cinder blocks


  • Harder to turn the pile without a mixing tool or by turning it manually with a shovel.
  • The design does not include leaching systems so water levels need to be carefully monitored
  • May take 6 months up to 2 years before being ready-to-use soil.

Tumbler bins

Tumber’s cost more than Stationary Composting Bins with prices ranging from around $100 up to $500. They have several advantages as well as disadvantages worth considering before adding one into your garden.


  • Easy mixing (they should be spun at least once per week)
  • Rodents cannot easily access them since they are elevated off ground level.
  • Decent amount of space so users can generate significant amounts sooner.
  • Decent ventilation system because they shouldn’t have too much stuff packed inside at once (ideal fill is around half full), reducing bacteria that make odors possible.


  • Expensive, with some models exceeding $500.
  • They tend to have smaller capacities than stationary Composting Bins.
  • Space may still be an issue if your garden has limited room. It will need a space that is easily accessible for spins every few days.

Worm composting bins

Worm composting bins are different from the previous methods because they use worms to break down organic material into nutrient-rich soil. These systems can cost up $100 upwards of $500, depending on their size and durability.


  • They typically do not produce any foul odors since worms do not produce any waste unlike other creatures and organisms
  • While it takes persistence & effort learning how to set them up correctly (worms like specific conditions), you can produce high-quality soil more quickly since the worms’ digestion process produces nutrient-rich castings in six months or less instead of one or two years having a Statuary Bin
  • Ideal fit for urban gardens or those too small for conventional options


  • Typically large up-front investment having worm-composting compared to Stationary Composting Bins.
  • The complexity of feeding worms may take time and research.

Keep in mind, the cost of materials needed when assembling a compost bin also needs to be considered even though for most people these costs would likely total no more than around about $20-30.

Key features to look for in a compost bin

Composting is an eco-friendly and cost-effective way of managing garden waste and food scraps. Apart from reducing landfill waste, composting enriches soil and enhances plant growth. A compost bin is the most convenient means of composting because it provides an enclosed environment that keeps organic matter contained while facilitating airflow and decomposition. However, with countless models in the market, choosing the right one may be daunting, especially if you’re new to composting. Besides budget considerations, here are some key features to look for in a quality compost bin for your garden:


Compost bins come in various materials, including wood, plastic, metal wire mesh or fencing material. Each material has its advantages and disadvantages based on factors such as durability, ventilation, weight, rodents resistance and aesthetics.

  • Wood: Wooden compost bins have a natural aesthetic appeal that blends well with most gardens’ visual appearance. If properly treated against rotting and termites infestation wooden bins can last several years but require maintenance.
  • Plastic: Plastic Compost Bin are lightweight yet durable; they can resist heat and moisture making them strong enough to withstand any level of wear-and-tear over time. They are also easy to clean compared to other materials thus hygienic.
  • Metal Wire Mesh: These types of Bins provide excellent ventilation thanks to their design that provides more space creating an area where aerobic bacteria thrive optimally due to proper oxygen supply they decompose faster than their counterparts do.
  • Fencing Material: An Extremely low-cost option is fencing material which is affordable yet light-weight. The non-solid design offers good air flow but sometimes rodents get through given how wide open this structure is.

It’s important to consider both functional properties (such as ventilation) and style when choosing your bin according to your preference.


Composting relies heavily on adequate airflow as this process requires oxygen for microbes that decompose organic matter to thrive. Therefore, an excellent compost bin features aeration vents or large openings that allow oxygen to circulate freely around your waste materials.

Compost bins with poor airflow tend to create an anaerobic environment resulting in the production of unwanted odors and slow decomposition. You can opt for models with removable tops as they make turning and mixing material easier, improving ventilation.


Rainfall or wet green materials may cause excess moisture to accumulate at the bottom, which may prevent airflow leading to the creation of bad smells. The good news is that most quality compost bins come fitted with drainage holes situated on the bottom sides for run-off water during disposal of excess liquid through its floor surface.

While picking this feature, inspect based on easy-to-clean qualities following its purpose of facilitating transportation from one point to another without exposing composters or handlers any risk of contamination.


Size matters when purchasing a compost bin. The right size depends on your needs determined by several factors like how much waste you generate and space available for storage. Ideally, choose a model that suits your gardening habits – if you produce plenty of garden waste throughout the year, go for a larger-sized bin. On average sizes in two types are often available in stores:

  • Small Composter: Typically assigned under 10 gallons capacity, cost less but it requires monitoring more frequently because they tend to fill up quickly.
  • Large Bins: Usually having greater than 12-gallon capacity bins and best suited for those who have vast gardens producing substantial quantities of scraps often at once it is quick and easy hence require minimal maintenance procedures ensuring their efficiency quotient stays high throughout long-term use.

Ultimately it comes down whether you want convenience over other features prioritized higher up such as budget constraints considered before starting your recycling journey!


Lastly, accessibility refers to how easily food scraps and other garden debris enter into the bin during disposal either organically or through a system of doors.

A model with easy access to its inside helps composters overcome the challenges of manual mixing, turning and monitoring. During winter seasons low temperatures can freeze waste materials which will require regular removal from bins to avoid toxins build-up around compost components in different stages between fermentation processes until final product ready for use.

In line with accessibility features, finely tuned systems such as stabilizers come in handy for enabling stackable composter designs ensuring that users can easily reach contents contained therein all while providing proper weight support levels.

To summarize, selecting a quality compost bin within your budget-friendly limits is purely dependent on one’s preference – certain features may be more valuable than others based on ease, budget constraints or functional needs. Consider factors like material type, aeration capacity, drainage properties, size/weight dimensions as well as those designed with convenience in mind when choosing the right compost bin for your gardening needs!

Composting tips and tricks

Composting is one of the easiest and most economical ways to recycle household waste while creating nutrient-rich soil for your garden. There are different types of compost bins you can choose from, but whichever you decide on, the following tips and tricks will help ensure your compost bin works effectively.

Maintaining a good balance of greens and browns

Your compost needs a good mix of green matter such as fruit and vegetable scraps, grass clippings, and coffee grounds. These provide nitrogen that speeds up the decomposition process. At the same time, you need brown materials like dry leaves, sawdust or wood chips that contain carbon. The carbon helps maintain temperature in the pile as well as absorb moisture.

Aim for 1:3 ratio between greens (nitrogen source) and browns (carbon source). Too much green matter may make it smelly while too many brown materials take longer to decompose.

Chopping up larger scraps

Breaking down bulkier items like branches or large pieces of vegetables increases surface area making it easier for microbes in the pile to break them down faster. You can chop these scraps into smaller pieces before adding them to your composter or use pruning shears to cut them into manageable sizes.

Turning or mixing the compost

Turning your compost regularly aerates it allowing oxygen to reach microorganisms breaking down the organic matter. Placing some pipe-like structures through your pile also enhances air movement throughout the heap.When stirring/mixing your compost with a pitchfork occasionally move items from outside layers inward for even decomposition through out

If you have an open-bottomed composter sitting directly on soil mixing isn’t needed because beneficial organisms like worms will come up through base helping breaking .

Adding water if the compost is too dry

Compost needs moisture to facilitate decomposition so its vital to add water when required–but don’t overwater because this will impede air movement. If you’re adding only dry brown materials but notice there’s an absence of green matter like fruit or veggie scraps consult your city must have a community compost program that welcomes.

Adding oxygen if the compost is too wet

If the pile smells putrid, and it appears to be slimy then it’s likely that you need to add more oxygen into the mix. The best solution is to turn over enough times (say once per week) to allow both better air transfer in addition to great bacteria move throughout.

Covering the compost

Compost needs to maintain warmth and moisture so covering it with heavy-duty plastic, lids or burlap sacks can help keep its heat and restrict excessive watering from rain which can potentially slow down compost’s decomposition process.

Adding compost activators

Composting might take much longer than usual sometimes especially when nitrogen content within your bin is low — if this ‘s the problem consider adding activators such as cow manure, garden soil, alfalfa meal or organic fertilizer., These along with other natural remedies contain beneficial microorganisms that activate breakdown of waste materials taking less time thus reducing decomposition time significantly..

It also helps to sprinkle a handful of bone meal on top after stirring the stuff around – this provides some extra phosphorus which encourages root development in plants later on!

Avoiding adding non-compostable items

Certain things simply aren’t fit for composing at home I.e. dairy products, meat, oils/butter/cheese are bad because they often invite pests while plastics reduce airflow; may remain undecomposed for long periods affecting those involved in handling/harvesting raw produce like gardeners giving them undesirable health effects .

Keep an eye out for any potential non-decomposable matter before throwing stuff into your composter, particularly those that cannot absorb carbon/nitrogen liquids — like glass shards or metal scrapings etc!

Maintaining your compost bin

Composting is one of the best ways to reduce waste and create nutrient-rich soil for your garden. However, once you have chosen the right compost bin for your needs, you need to maintain it properly to ensure that it functions at its best. Here are some tips on how to keep your compost bin healthy and productive.

Regularly turning or mixing the compost

To make sure that all of the organic material in your compost bin breaks down evenly, you should turn or mix it regularly. This helps to aerate the compost, which allows beneficial bacteria and microorganisms to thrive. Turning also prevents clumping and ensures that all materials are being broken down at an even pace.

How often you turn or mix your compost will depend on a variety of factors including the size of your bin, the amount of organic material you add, and how quickly you want finished compost. As a general rule of thumb, though, aim to agitate your pile every week or two.

Adding water if the compost is too dry

Composting requires moisture so if your pile becomes too dry, it may slow down decomposition. You can add water with either a hose or watering can as needed so that everything retains a similar consistency.

In addition to ensuring that there’s enough moisture in there for everything to break down efficiently over time; having moist ingredients means worms and other creatures are able to access them more easily!

Too little water can also cause unpleasant smells – like rotting food scraps – which nobody wants around their home or garden (especially during summer months).

Adding oxygen if the compost is too wet

On the other hand, an overly wet heap isn’t good either since it hampers air circulation necessary for decomposers growth in preventing smell,

If your pile appears soggy- refrain from adding additional moisture until you improve drainage conditions by checking:

  • The drainage hole
  • If outdoor: place bin over well-draining soil

Checking the temperature of the compost

In hot, active composting process, the center of the bin can reach between 130-170F. Where temperatures have been high for an extended time period (above 160 degrees Fahrenheit), pathogens and weed seeds will be killed leading to producing rich and fertile soil.

Therefore, it’s important to monitor your heap temperature with a simple thermometer or long skewer -start in the middle- every few days when you’re first getting started, and after adding any new materials. This helps track how things are progressing and notice any issues before they become serious.

A buildup can occur if there’s lack of oxygen so turning the pile will correct it although if the layer is too compacted, it might require rebuilding altogether!

Removing finished compost

Pries off finished compost from bottom or sides using a garden fork until only unprocessed items remain. If you’re planning on using it immediately by adding to planting beds,

Some bins include doors that allow removal within less effort; others require disassembly before removal. Either way works fine so choose according to your preferences.

Finished soil color depends on various types of waste that have been decomposed, ranging from brown-black coffee grounds combining green grass clippings which yield dark brown nutrient-rich matter.

Overall, by maintaining your compost bin properly you’ll not only produce healthy plants but also help minimize landfill waste while recycling all sorts of organic materials!

Troubleshooting common composting problems

Composting is a natural process that can have some hiccups along the way. Here are some common problems that may arise in your compost bin and how to troubleshoot them.

Foul odors

One of the most common problems with compost bins is foul odors. These odors are usually caused by an overabundance of wet materials, like food scraps and grass clippings, which can begin to rot and emit a bad smell.

To fix this problem:

  • First, make sure you’re not putting any meat, bones, or dairy products in your bin as these items can cause odors
  • Then, add more dry materials like leaves or shredded paper to balance out the wetness
  • Turn or mix your compost more frequently to increase airflow and break down materials faster
  • Finally, consider adding some garden lime or wood ash to help neutralize any smells.

Slow decomposition

If your compost pile isn’t breaking down as quickly as you’d like it to, there are a few potential causes.

Firstly, ensure that you have enough green materials such as vegetable scraps or grass clippings for nitrogen content; on average two-thirds of green matter is needed within one’s composter. Additionally might addin appropriate brown material such as cardboard for carbon content which usually makes up the other third. Having too much carbon-rich “brown” material without enough nitrogen-rich “green” material will cause slow decomposition rates.

Other causes may include:

  • Lack of oxygen due to infrequent turning: Turning your compost every 3 days will result in faster decomposition.
  • An overly wet or dry environment: sprinkle water if it’s dry & avoid adding new materials if it’s already highly saturated.

Lastly, is possible that hot temperatures are damaging bacteria proliferation necessary for quick decomposition – try adding another layer of raw organic material and turn the composter immediately afterwards.


It’s frustrating to find pests in your compost bin. Some common culprits include fruit flies, ants, rats, and raccoons.

To avoid unwanted guests:

  • Firstly, ensure that meat, fish or dairy products are not put into the composter as it’ll be too attractive for larger animals.
  • Secondly placing a wire mesh around any areas where wild animals can enter your composter is also wise.

To avoid annoying fruit flies and gnats consider:

  • Burying fresh food waste under soil which usually helps.
  • If paper/cardboard egg cartons are available they can be placed on the top layer of fresh food waste before adding other green materials on top.
  • Finally placing a vinegar trap close to the compost bin will attract and kill many of them.

Excessive moisture

An excess amount of moisture within your compost pile is a common issue. This occurs when too many water-rich ingredients such as fruit scraps or freshly cut grass are added without enough dry matter like leaves or wood chips.

To restore balance to your composter:

  • Reduce the number of kitchen scraps you add in
  • Increase the number of brown (dry) items you mix in such as dry leaves
  • Turn it over regularly to allow oxygen to infiltrate & prevent stagnation

Heat buildup

Compost piles create heat by bacterial activity breaking down organic materials. Compost bins with high levels of nitrogen-rich “Green” material with ample turning experience significant heat increases reaching temperatures up to 180°F which help break down pathogens but may not suit everyone’s ecological needs.

If there is too much heat then simply give it time to cool off -if this takes over 2 weeks serious attention should be given otherwise constantly adding new layers without turning properly may increase exposure temp related pathogen remains.

                                                                    - -end--
Scroll to Top